This article originally appeared in Colorado Public Radio Nov. 19 2026

The Colorado Court of Appeals ruled Thursday that Colorado Parks and Wildlife violated a state law regarding public comments when it changed the regulations applied to state wildlife areas in 2023.

The changes included making certain areas off-limits to people who wanted to observe wildlife, while allowing hunters and fishers in the same areas. The Friends of Animals, River Runners for Wilderness, and Living River groups, filed a lawsuit against Colorado Parks and Wildlife, or CPW, opposing the new rules.

“We were concerned that these specific regulations really discriminated against people who wanted to observe wildlife but not hunt and fish in state wildlife areas. That CPW is essentially severely restricting the activities of people who are not hunting and fishing in these areas,” said Stephen Hernick, the attorney representing the three groups. 

CPW manages about 350 lands and waters designated by the Colorado Parks and Wildlife Commission so that wildlife populations could thrive and people could go and see wildlife. The concern was that as more people used the lands, it could have a negative impact on the wildlife, so the commission proposed changes. 

Opened site for commenters

In April 2023, CPW released the proposal, opening it for public comment through the site “Engage CPW”. In the six weeks of public comments, it received 191 comments through the website and seven emails regarding the changes. 

Hernick said that while hashing the new rules out in court, CPW said that the rule-making commission didn’t take any of the online public comments into consideration. 

“We had assumed that CPW had considered all public comments submitted,” Hernick said. “We were frankly pretty stunned when CPW’s attorneys told us. ‘Actually, no, CPW didn’t consider any of these comments that were submitted to Engage CPW.’” 

The court’s opinion cited that CPW estimated a quarter of the Engage CPW commenters generally agreed with the proposed rule changes for state wildlife areas, commonly called SWAs, according to the court’s opinion. 

Comments that opposed changes

Many disagreed with the proposed changes, with several comments saying they disagree with the rules allowing hunters to access areas, but not wildlife viewers. 

Others were concerned that hunting dogs would be allowed in some areas, but a person and their dog wouldn’t. 

One commenter wrote, “You should allow non-motorized boaters to use these areas for access to recreational boating. Using these areas for out-ins and take-outs does not interfere with fishing or hunting. You should not exclude user groups in this way.” 

Another said, “CPW should protect the wildlife and their habitat that exist on SWAs. Instead, CPW may actually be harming wildlife and their habitat by arbitrarily favoring the activities of hunters and fishers who kill and remove wildlife from SWAs.” 

Another commenter wrote: “I live in Carbondale and feel that it is unfair to only allow fishing/hunting on the Roaring for rivers. The stretch of the Roaring Fork River from Aspen to Glenwood Spring should be allowed to all, not just hunters and fishermen. I understand the pressure being put on the River but at least make it equitable by permitting – I never thought I’d say that – or at least allow fishing and recreation during certain times. There has to be another way to do this as opposed to closing it to some water users.”

A matter of transparency

It brings transparency into question. The appeal court’s opinion said that CPW didn’t take the majority of the public comments into consideration despite a CPW press release inviting the public to provide feedback.

“The disappointing thing for us was that CPW didn’t recognize this error, didn’t recognize that, ‘Oh there was, there was clearly some confusion here that we caused by encouraging people to submit comments to Engage CPW,’” Hernick said. “I would like to think that a state agency in a situation like that would kind of own up to it there, would own up to its mistake.”

He hoped CPW would recognize that and go back to the drawing board to consider the comments.

Over the past three years, he said it’s limited access to state wildlife areas.

“What the agency was doing here, it was prioritizing hunting and fishing over all other types of wildlife-related recreation,” he said. “ Essentially non-hunters and non-fishers were severely restricted in what they could do or even SWAs that they could access.”

What’s next

The case came to the appeals court after a district court found that CPW’s new rules didn’t arbitrarily favor hunters and fishers and that CPW had substantially complied with the state’s rulemaking laws. 

The appeals court reversed that decision, saying that CPW violated state law because it opened public comment on proposed rules using a communication method not mentioned in the official notice of rulemaking. And when CPW didn’t include the comments in the record or consider them in the final rules, it violates the rulemaking provisions of the State Administrative Procedure Act. 

“Colorado Parks and Wildlife, invited the public to submit comments to its proposed state wildlife area rules on its online platform. Nearly 200 people did so,” the opinion said. “But the agency concedes that those comments were never presented to or considered by the agency decision-makers who promulgated the final rules, nor were the comments included in the rulemaking record.” 

CPR reached out to CPW for comment and received an emailed statement: “CPW is still evaluating the Colorado Court of Appeals’ recent decision and determining next steps.”